In our quest to make information a little more free, we keep an eye out for interesting requests and uses of FOI information. All of the stuff we’re looking at can be found here anytime you like, and if you have any suggestions, please send them on over to tips@muckrock.com.
Moving on to the main event:
Has The Charlotte Observer’s ‘e-mailgate’ eroded your trust in the media? In a recent scandal in North Carolina, the Charlotte Observer filed a FOI request and received nearly 20,000 e-mail addresses of citizens and businesses signed up to government newsletters. Though they now insist that they have no intention of using the e-mail addresses, the fact that they were able to acquire them seems to be a misuse of the FOIA, which exists to further government transparency, not to give anyone access to individuals’ information. What do you think? Is what the Observer did okay in your book? Do you think they should be allowed to file such requests? Who watches the watchdogs?
High Price for India’s Information Law: India’s FOI law has been in effect for five years now, but the controversy over it still rages. Just over a week ago, activist Amit Jethwa was murdered after he filed a request for information about the illegal mines near Gir National Park. Over several years, Mr. Jethwa had been attempting to discover who owned the mines and what action was taken against them. After discovering that one of the mines’ backers was influential politician Dinubhai Solanki, Amit was beaten by unknown assailants. His assassination came just after he filed a lawsuit against the mines.
SEC transparency faulted by watchdog group: A recent report filed by watchdog organization the Project on Government Oversight revealed that, thought the SEC has released documentation of their investigations of, for example, Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, they have not previously released reports on a series of conflict-of-interest situations. According to an SEC spokesperson, the SEC is dedicated to transparency and releases all audits to the public.
Documents raise questions on treatment of detainees: The ACLU has released thousands of documents on prisoner conditions in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Guantanamo Bay that detail the harsh treatment and what the ACLU considers to be “unjustified homicides” from the prisons. The requests, obtained from a 2009 FOIA request, show 190 prisoner deaths, 25-30 of which the ACLU says were arbitrary and unjustifiable. The DoD denies any unlawfulness, saying that it takes the fair and ethical treatment of prisoners very seriously.